Why Being The Most Connected Is A Vanity Metric
My 6’5” dad was black and grew up in one of the most dangerous cities in America. He sported a huge afro into the early 90s when he died at the age of 33; one year older than I am now.
My mother, a white, Jewish refugee from Poland, arrived in Brooklyn when she was 17 with no money and no English. She essentially raised me as a single mother
One of the leading applied network scientists, , an associate professor at the University of Virginia McIntire School of Commerce, offers a critical development in understanding networks:
“Traditionally, self-help books on networks focus on going out and building big mammoth rolodexes…What we’ve found is that this isn’t what high-performers do. What seems to distinguish the top 20% of performers across a wide-range of organizations is not so much a big network. In fact, there is usually a negative statistically significant likelihood of being a top performer and knowing a lot of people.” (via )
If being the most connected person isn’t the best strategy or even an effective strategy, what is?
is the Hobart W. Williams Professor Professor of Sociology and Strategy at the University of Chicago Booth School of Business. He is the leading academic researcher in the world studying the ways that social networks create competitive advantage in careers, organizations, and markets.
Burt’s research gives insight into a strategy that has become one of the most reliable and replicated findings in network science over the last 30 years.
However, before we understand the strategy, we need to have a better understanding of network science.
A basic pattern of network science is . People tend to gravitate to clusters for a lot of reasons whether it be working in the same company or industry, living in a neighborhood, or going to the same school. These clusters get stronger as people gain mutual friendships, establish norms, and build reputations.
This clustering tendency has two consequences:
· Information travels more quickly and you hear the same information repeatedly within any group. In Burt’s words, “People tire of repeating arguments and stories explaining why they believe and behave the way they do and develop shorthand symbols and even dialects. Knowledge becomes unwritten but mutually understood.”
· As a result of groups using shorthand, it is hard for individuals from other groups to understand the full value and relevance of what is being said. In other words, information becomes ‘sticky’ and does not easily move from one group to another if at all. Translation is required for the ‘dialect’ of one group to be understood by another group.
One large example that we can all relate to is the gap between those just entering the workforce and those in their 50s and 60s. For many adults, the abbreviated words of 20-somethings are impossible to decipher. On the other hand, 20-somethings do not fully appreciate the unwritten codes of how business is really done.
Most people stay within the same groups they start in because it is comfortable and validating. Most people who were born as a Democrat, stay a Democrat. Most people born as Christian stay Christian. Most people stay in the same industry they started in.
Within groups, we get mastery. We build reputation. People like us. We become more efficient coordinating with others. We form our identity within a group.
A key insight from network science is the power of brokering, the act of moving information from one group to another. Burt explains, “What a broker does is make a sticky information market more fluid. Great ideas will never move if we wait for them to be spoken in the same language.”
Network brokers (ie – connectors) have three advantages:
· They pull their information from diverse clusters.
· While they may not be the first to hear information, they are first to introduce information to another cluster.
· They develop skills in translating one group’s knowledge into another’s insight.
Combined these three advantages give an individual an overall vision advantage to see, create, and take advantage of opportunities.
In a groundbreaking, widely replicated study of 8 different populations, Burt showed that simply being in an open network instead of a closed one is an extremely good predictor of career success. In an open network, everyone doesn’t already know each other. As a result, you are in between many different clusters. In a closed network, everyone already knows each other.
As you can see in the chart below, the further to the right you go toward a closed network, the more you’ll repeatedly hear the same ideas, which reaffirm what you already believe. The further left you go toward an open network, the more you’ll be exposed to new ideas. People to the left are significantly more successful than those to the right.
The study shows that half of the predicted differences in career success within a line of work (i.e., — promotion, compensation, industry recognition) can be explained by the extent to which a person is a network broker (i.e. connecting different clusters). No other factor was more important in predicting career success!
Brokerage helps give context to why and are so powerful. It also shines a light on an often underappreciated part of introductions – translation. While it may be obvious to the broker how two people in different clusters should connect, it may not be obvious to the two people. Therefore, it is worth devoting extra attention to helping helping others see the same opportunity you see.
Brokerage is more than just a tactic to be deployed. It requires a completely different way of seeing and being in the world that is often uncomfortable.
Being deeply connected and respected while having a high status in a single network feels good.
On the other hand, being a broker means pulling from diverse perspectives that may seem conflicting. This requires intellectual flexibility. It means often being an outsider. It means less stability.
Ideas that are obviously beneficial to you because of your unique place in your network might seem trivial and risky to someone deeply inside a network.
By becoming a person who can become comfortable in this environment, you become someone who can more easily leverage brokering.
In order to be an effective broker, you must continually fight against the comfort and validation that comes from staying in one group.
, President and CEO of the , has built her career on being what she calls a ‘tri-sector athlete’. Pulling from her diverse experience in the government, for-profit, and nonprofit sectors, she has brokered global partnerships to help solve some of the world’s largest challenges.
Kathy has developed a 15-minute meeting policy where she takes meetings with people she wouldn’t normally connect with. This exposes her to new networks while still maintaining her fast-paced schedule.
This policy has been extremely beneficial. One example is a 2005 meeting with who was in her late twenties and had just returned from spending two years in a remote village in Bolivia with the Peace Corps. The meeting was in November. By March of the next year, Elizabeth joined the UN Foundation in a newly co-created position. Elizabeth went on to create the Foundation’s largest campaigns, Nothing But Nets, Shot@Life, and Girl Up. Today, Elizabeth is the first-ever Resident Entrepreneur leading their work on innovation and entrepreneurship.
We are in a renaissance period for network science. It is only in the past few years that billions of people have connected to each other via global networks (ie – Facebook, Linkedin, Twitter, & Google) and started to publicly share in trillions of ways.
It is the field of network science that is perhaps best poised to understand this massive data. On the other hand, it is us as entrepreneurs who may be best poised to understand how the discoveries of network science apply to our day-to-day lives.
What we now know is that the simple act of constantly putting yourself in an open network, a network where people aren’t connected to each other, will give you a huge advantage in your career. It will give you a vision advantage that allows you capitalize on new amazing opportunities. More importantly, it will expose you to the conditions you need in order to build the skill-set and mindset of a network broker.
Growing up ‘uncomfortable’ gave me the freedom to create an identity that wasn’t based completely on belonging to one group. This made it easier for me to go against the grain and make two of the most important decisions in my career; starting a business at 16 when no one else I knew was an entrepreneur and taking a semester off from college to write a book against the strong pushback from people closest to me.
Each of these decisions required tremendous leaps of faith that my unique upbringing ultimately made it easier to make.
Throughout my career, I’ve continued to surround myself in new groups.Today, , the organization I co-founded, helps connect the country’s top young entrepreneurs to new groups they normally wouldn’t connect with including the US Chamber of Commerce, United Nations Foundation, and the White House. We translate the objectives of each group in order to create platforms that help entrepreneurs give back.